Skip to main content

Will Kartarpur Corridor bring paradigm shift in India, Pakistan ties?



Amid the friction prevailing between South Asian neighbors India and Pakistan, the launching of the Kartarpur Corridor is nothing less than a paradigm shift for this region.
First proposed by India in 1999 when the then Prime Minister Vajpayee visited Lahore, this channel could not be built due to lack of trust between the two nations. After many years, the debate over opening Kartarpur re-started when cricketer turned politician Navjot Singh Sidhu attended the swearing in of his old friend Imran Khan as the Prime Minister of Pakistan.
At this occasion the Pakistani army chief General Bajwa told him that Pakistan was thinking of opening the corridor. Even though Sidhu faced a severe backlash for being “over friendly” in Pakistan once he went home, his visit has proved to be a catalyst in re-energizing Indo-Pak relations.
Considering that both countries do not get along most of the time, the breakthrough is nothing less than a miracle. At a time when even the annual summit of the South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (SAARC) is held up because of these two nations, such a major practical step towards normalizing ties is unexpected.
Practically though, such a sea-change is not possible without high-level back channel talks between India and Pakistan. And if that is the case, India-Pakistan ties are already on a positive new trajectory as the opening of this channel is no small feat. Ostensibly, once Pakistan took the lead and showed willingness to open the Kartarpur route, the Indian government complied due to several reasons.
If the Kartarpur channel is successfully completed, the opening of more corridors is possible and visa-free access to more shrines on both sides of the Indo-Pak border can be given
Sabena Siddiqui

Elections around the corner

For starters, this was what India has been demanding since two decades. Secondly, with elections around the corner, the BJP government in New Delhi would like to cash in on the Sikh vote bank. Fulfilling a long-standing demand for visa-free access by the Sikh religious community, this new route facilitates their cross-border pilgrimages.
Located across the Ravi river flowing into Pakistan, the Kartarpur Sahib shrine is built at the spot where spiritual leader Guru Nanak passed away and special celebrations are taking place this year on his 550th birth anniversary.
Thirdly, both countries can benefit from trade links by land. Significantly, for the first time since the partition of the sub-continent, land access has been given to India inside Pakistan.
It can be termed the first turning point toward amicable relations in 70 years, India has wished for a land route via Pakistan since long as it would link it to Afghanistan and onward to Central Asia. Likewise, improved bilateral links can open new trade opportunities for Pakistan and help improve its economy.
If this thaw in relations continues, it holds infinite possibilities and signifies a geopolitical shift. Unfortunately, such ‘new beginnings’ in the past have yielded disappointing results as Indo-Pakistan relations follow a pattern of ‘highs and lows’. Whenever the bonhomie increases, prospects hit rock-bottom very fast.
If the Kartarpur channel is successfully completed, the opening of more corridors is possible and visa-free access to more shrines on both sides of the Indo-Pak border can be given. Up till now, pilgrimages between both countries came under the ambit of the 1974 Protocol on Visits to Religious Shrines which makes visas compulsory.

‘Corridor of peace’

Performing the ground -breaking ceremony, Pakistan’s Prime Minister Imran Khan has called it the ‘corridor of peace’ and urged both countries to ‘move forward and break their chains with the past,’ citing the example of France and Germany who fought many wars but have amicable relations today.
Welcoming the development, the Indian Prime Minister Narender Modi also said that, “Had anyone ever thought that the Berlin Wall would fall. Maybe with the blessings of Guru Nanak Devji, this Kartarpur corridor will not remain just a corridor, but act as a bridge between the peoples of the two countries.”
However, the Indian Foreign Minister Sushma Swaraj decided not to attend the event but Sidhu and two Union ministers Harsimrat Kaur Badal and Hardeep Singh Puri represented the Indian side.
Publicly, the Indian response is subdued but the construction of the corridor has already started from their side of the border since the Indian cabinet approved the proposal.
If Sushma Swaraj had attended the inauguration, her presence would have elevated the meetings to the level of a bilateral dialogue and such talks have not taken place between both the nations since quite a while. Apparently, the imminent elections may be the reason why the ruling party is hesitating from upgrading links with Pakistan immediately.
Even though the total distance of this ‘corridor of peace’ as the Pakistani PM calls it, is only four kilometers, it has taken a long journey fraught with misunderstandings and friction to reach here. The future depends on whether both sides sustain positive dialogue, restore amicable terms, enhance trade ties and nurture more people to people links.
_________________________
Sabena Siddiqui is a foreign affairs journalist and geopolitical analyst with special focus on the Belt and Road Initiative, CPEC and South Asia. She tweets @sabena_siddiqi.
Last Update: Friday, 7 December 2018 KSA 08:46 - GMT 05:46
Disclaimer: Views expressed by writers in this section are their own and do not reflect Al Arabiya English's point-of-view.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

#BeltandRoadForum : a new way forward

The Belt and Road Forum: a new way forward By Sabena Siddiqui 0   Comment(s) Print   E-mail China.org.cn, May 10, 2017 Adjust font size:     The upcoming Belt and Road Forum for International Cooperation will serve as a powerful reminder of the Belt and Road project’s dedication to win-win international development. [Zhang Xueshi/China.org.cn]  The Belt and Road Forum for International Cooperation will be held in Beijing on May 14 and 15; it will be hosted by President Xi himself, who will address an opening ceremony attended by at least 28 heads of state and more than 60 global organizations. Pakistani PM Nawaz Sharif will lead a Pakistani delegation to the forum, and later he will have a meeting with President Xi and attend the round-table summit for leaders. The forum promises to be the biggest diplomatic event of the year, with greater attendance than both the NATO and the upcoming EUCO summits. The audience of 1,200 people includes UN ...

Is China opening up to the world via Belt Road Initiative?

Rebranding modern China today, the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) is a focal part of Chinese foreign policy as well as the basis of its domestic economic strategy. Titled “Vision and Actions on Jointly Building Silk Road Economic Belt and 21st Century Maritime Silk Road”, the official document signifies the “opening up” of China to the world. China has not looked back since the successful implementation of Deng Xiaopeng’s reforms in 1978 and it wants to share its expertise and experience with the world by executing an open economic venture for all. Unfortunately, the Belt and Road Initiative has been received with suspicion on the whole by the Western bloc and its allies. In the beginning, it was considered an alternative to the ASEAN grouping in the region but as time passed it became more large-scale and experts started linking up BRI with the “String of Pearls” theory. Coined by defense contractor  Booz Allen Hamilton  in his research study in 2005, this term descri...

Hopes high for the Saudi Vision 2030

In the aftermath of Crown Prince Mohammad bin Salman’s unveiling of the unprecedented Vision 2030 reforms, a sense of renaissance seems to exist in Saudi Arabia. Diversifying the oil economy along new routes for rapid progress, it is definitely the brainchild of the young Prince; however, he modestly insists he is only "one of 20 million people. I am nothing without them." Nevertheless, such a holistic package for economic, cultural and societal reform has not been seen before in recent Saudi history. Opening up Saudi Arabia to the world, the Prince announced his country would become "moderate" and "open" and that he would "eradicate" radical Islamist ideology. "We are returning to what we were before -- a country of moderate Islam open to all religions and to the world," he told an audience of world luminaries attending a major investment conference in the country. Announcing a futuristic new city named "NEOM," 33...